Abstract
We analyze UK and US experiences as they relate to two central net neutrality questions: (1) whether competition serves as a deterrent to the discriminatory treatment of Internet traffic, and (2) whether discrimination creates barriers to application development and innovation. Relying on consumer switching behavior to provide more comprehensive competitive discipline was insufficient for a variety of reasons, including the presence of switching costs. The process of correcting errors in the technology used for application-specific management revealed that such management creates costs for application developers and innovators, regardless of whether their products are targeted for traffic management.
- Atherton, M. 2010. BT response to Ofcom consultation on traffic management. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/net-neutrality/responses/BT.pdf.Google Scholar
- Bangeman, E. 2007. Comcast traffic blocking: Even more apps, groupware clients affected. http://arstechnica.com/uncategorized/2007/10/comcast-traffic-blocking-even-more-apps-groupware-clients-affected/.Google Scholar
- Bar, F., Cohen, S., Cowhey, P., DeLong, B., Kleeman M., and Zysman, M. 2000. Access and innovation policy for the third-generation Internet. Telecomm. Policy 24, 6--7, 489--518.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Becker, G. S., Carlton, D. W., and Sider, H. S. 2010. Net neutrality and consumer welfare. J. Compet. Law Econ. 6, 3, 497--519,Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- BIS and DCMS. 2009. Digital Britain final report. UK Government report. http://www.umic.pt/images/stories/publicacoes3/digitalbritain-finalreport-jun09.pdf.Google Scholar
- Bourreau, M., Kourandi, F., and Valletti, T. 2013. Net neutrality with competing Internet platforms. Working paper, Telecom ParisTech Department of Economics and Social Sciences. http://pareto.uab.es/sempdf/micro/2013/Valletti.pdf.Google Scholar
- Broadband Stakeholder Group. 2011. Broadband providers launch new traffic management transparency code. http://www.broadbanduk.org/wpcontent/uploads/2012/08/broadband_providers_launch_new_traffic_management_transparency_code_14_march_201111.pdf.Google Scholar
- Brianl. 2011. Consolidated latency tracking and reporting. http://us.battle.net/wow/en/forum/topic/1965992365?page=7#122.Google Scholar
- Brill, E. 2009. Hart v. Comcast, proposed class action settlement for Lotus Notes throttling. http://www.edbrill.com/ebrill/edbrill.nsf/dx/hart-v.-comcast-proposed-class-action-settlement-for-lotus-notes-throttling.Google Scholar
- Brooksy. 2010. Re: BT throttling P2P traffic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! http://community.bt.com/t5/BB-Speed-Connection-Issues/BT-Throttling-P2P-Traffic/m-p/56929.Google Scholar
- Brown, C. J. and Boucher, T. M. 2007. Comments of Qwest Communications International Inc. Matter of broadband industry practices. WC Docket no. 07-52. https://prodnet.www.neca.org/publicationsdocs/wwpdf/101210qwest.pdf.Google Scholar
- Casserly, J. L., Wallach, R. G., Alvarez, D. K., Walker, H. C., Waz, J. W., Zachem, K. A., McManus, M., Nathan, T. R., and Lewis, G. J. 2008. Reply comments of Comcast Corporation in the matter of broadband industry practices. WC Docket no. 07--52. http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=6519856208Google Scholar
- Cave, M. and Crocioni, P. 2007. Does Europe need network neutrality rules? Int. J. Comm. 1, 669--679.Google Scholar
- Chirico, F., Haar, I. M. V. D., and Larouche, P. 2007. Network neutrality in the EU. Tilburg Law and Economics discussion paper no. 2007--030. https://pure.uvt.nl/portal/files/860692/networkneutrality.pdf.Google Scholar
- Dutton, W. H., di Gennaro, C., and Millwood Hargrave, A. 2005. The Internet in Britain: The Oxford Internet survey (OxIS). Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford. http://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/research/publications/Google Scholar
- Dutton, W. H. and Blank, G. 2011. Next generation users: The Internet in Britain 2011. Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford. http://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/research/publications/.Google Scholar
- Economides, N. 2008. Net neutrality, non-discrimination and digital distribution of content through the internet, I/S J. Law Policy Inf. Soc. 4, 209.Google Scholar
- ECTA. 2010. Public consultation on the open Internet and net neutrality in Europe. http://www.ectaportal.com/en/POLICY/Positions/2010/-print/.Google Scholar
- Faulhaber, G. R. and Farber, D. J. 2010. The open Internet: A customer-centric framework. Int. J. Comm. 4, 302--342.Google Scholar
- FCC. 2010. Report and order in the matter of preserving the open Internet. GN Docket 09-1913; broadband industry practices. WC Docket 07-52. http://www.fcc.gov/document/preserving-open-internet.Google Scholar
- FCC. 2012. Internet access services. http://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2012/db0614/DOC-314630A1.pdf.Google Scholar
- Government Accountability Office. 2006. Broadband deployment is extensive throughout the United States, but it is difficult to assess the extent of deployment gaps in rural areas. GAO-06-426. http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d06426.pdf.Google Scholar
- Guo, H., Cheng, H. K., and Bandyopadhyay, S. 2012. Net neutrality, broadband market coverage, and innovation at the edge. Decis. Sci. 43, 1, 141--172.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Jackson, M. 2011. UPD UK ISP TalkTalk uses traffic management to block users from playing OnLive. http://www.ispreview.co.uk/story/2011/09/30/uk-isp-talktalk-uses-traffic-management-to-block-customers-from-playing-onlive.html.Google Scholar
- Jon, S. 2011. World of Warcraft latency and lag spikes. http://community.virginmedia.com/t5/Up-to-30Mb-Setup-Equipment/World-of-Warcraft-latency-and-lag-spikes/m-p/349083/highlight/true#M151086.Google Scholar
- Hahn, R. W., Litan, R. E., and Singer, H. J. 2007. The economics of wireless ‘net neutrality’. J. Compet. Law Econ. 3, 3, 399--451.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Kantar Media. 2012. OCI tracker benchmark study q3 2012. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/other/telecoms-research/copyright-infringement-tracker/Google Scholar
- Kisielowska-Lipman, M. 2012. Lost on the broadband super highway: Consumer understanding of information on traffic management. http://www.consumerfocus.org.uk/files/2012/11/Lost-on-the-broadband-super-highway.pdf.Google Scholar
- Krafft, J. and Salies, E. 2008. The diffusion of ADSL and costs of switching Internet providers in the broadband industry: Evidence from the French case. Res. Policy 37, 4, 706--719.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Lehr, W. E., Gillett, S. E., Sirbu, M. A., and Peha, J. M. 2006. Scenarios for the network neutrality arms race. Int. J. Comm. 1, 607--643.Google Scholar
- Lemley, M. A. and Lessig, L. 2001. The end of end-to-end: Preserving the architecture of the Internet in the broadband era. UCLA Law Rev. 48, 925.Google Scholar
- Lennett, B. 2009. Dis-empowering users vs. maintaining Internet freedom: Network management and quality of service (QoS). Comm. Law Conspectus 18, 1, 97.Google Scholar
- Lessig, L. 2001. The Future of Ideas: The Fate of the Commons in a Connected World. Random House Digital. Google Scholar
Digital Library
- Litan, R. E. and Singer, H. J. 2007. Unintended consequences of net neutrality regulation. J. Telecomm. High Tech. Law. 5, 3, 533.Google Scholar
- London Economics. 2011. Consumer information on broadband speed and net neutrality experiment. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/netneutrality/statement/Consumer_information1.pdf.Google Scholar
- Marsden, C. T. 2007. Net neutrality and consumer access to content. SCRIPT-ed. 4, 4, 407--435.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Marsden, C. T. 2010. Net Neutrality: Towards a Co-Regulatory Solution. Bloomsbury Academic, London. Google Scholar
Digital Library
- Nuechterlein, J. E. 2009. Antitrust oversight of an antitrust dispute: An institutional perspective on the net neutrality debate. J. Telecomm. High Tech. Law 7, 1, 19.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2006. The consumer experience research report. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/market-data/consumer-experience-reports/report/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2008. Voluntary code of practice: Broadband speeds. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/telecoms/codes-of-practice/broadband-speeds-cop/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2009a. UK broadband speeds 2009. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/other/telecoms-research/broadband-speeds/broadband_speeds/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2009b. The consumer experience 2009. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/market-data/consumer-experience-reports/eval09/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2010a. Review of the wholesale broadband access markets: Consultation on market definition, market power determinations and remedies. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/consultations/wholesale-broadband-markets/summary.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2010b. UK broadband speeds. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/other/telecoms-research/broadband-speeds/broadband-speeds-2010/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2010c. Review of the wholesale broadband access markets: Second consultation on market definition, market power determinations and remedies. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/consultations/wholesale-broadband-markets/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2010d. Strategic review of consumer switching: A consultation on switching processes in the UK communications sector. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/consumer-switching/summary/switching.pdf.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2011. Approach to net neutrality. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/consultations/net-neutrality/statement/.Google Scholar
- Ofcom. 2013. The consumer experience 2012. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/market-data-research/market-data/consumer-experience-reports/consumer-experience-12/.Google Scholar
- Reggiani, C. and Valletti, T. 2012. Net neutrality and innovation at the core and at the edge. University of Manchester School of Economics Discussion Paper Series 1202. http://www.socialsciences.manchester.ac.uk/medialibrary/economics/discussionpapers/EDP-1202.pdf.Google Scholar
- Richmond, S. 2011. Superfast broadband ‘for 90 percent of Britain by 2015’. The Telegraph, May 12th.Google Scholar
- Rosen, A. 2012. File 545613, Internet traffic management practice (‘ITMP’). Section 36 of the Telecommunications Act, S.C.1993, c.38, as amended (‘Act’), and Paragraphs 126 and 127 of Telecom Regulatory Policy. CRTC 2009-657.Google Scholar
- Sandvig, C. 2007. Network neutrality is the new common carriage. Info: The J. Policy Regulat. Strategy Telecomm. Inf. Media 9, 2/3, 136--147.Google Scholar
- Sidak, J. G. 2006. A consumer-welfare approach to network neutrality regulation of the Internet. J. Compet. Law Econ. 2, 3, 349.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Shelanski, H. A. 2007. Adjusting regulation to competition: Toward a new model for U.S. telecommunications policy. Yale J. Regulat. 24, 1, 55.Google Scholar
- Sky. 2010. Response by British Sky Broadcasting Group PLC to Ofcom’s discussion document ‘traffic management and net neutrality’. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/net-neutrality/responses/Sky.pdf.Google Scholar
- Skype. 2010. Skype comments on Ofcom discussion paper ‘traffic management and net neutrality’. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/net-neutrality/responses/Skype.pdf.Google Scholar
- Sluijs, J. P., Schuett, F., and Henze, B. 2011. Transparency regulation in broadband markets: Lessons from experimental research. Telecomm. Policy 35, 7, 592--602. Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- TalkTalk Group. 2010a. Traffic management and ‘net neutrality’: A discussion document. http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/consultations/net-neutrality/responses/TTG.pdf.Google Scholar
- TalkTalk Group. 2010b. European commission consultation / Questionnaire on open Internet and net neutrality in Europe. TalkTalk Group Response.Google Scholar
- Tambini, D. 2012. Consumer representation in UK communications policy and regulation. Inf. 14, 2, 3--16.Google Scholar
Cross Ref
- Telefónica. 2010. Response to: ‘Traffic management and net neutrality’: A discussion document. http://oti.newamerica.net/publications/resources/2010/response_to_ofcom_consultation_on_traffic_management_and_net_neutrality.Google Scholar
- Thompson, K. 2011. Re: Complaint regarding Rogers’ Internet traffic management practices; file # 522253 and file # 517209. https://openmedia.ca/sites/openmedia.ca/files/Rogers%20ITMP%20Complaint%20March%2029%202011.pdf.Google Scholar
- van Schewick, B. 2007. Towards an economic framework for network neutrality regulation. J. Telecomm. High Technol. Law 5, 2, 329--391.Google Scholar
- van Schewick, B. 2010. Internet Architecture and Innovation. MIT Press. Google Scholar
Digital Library
- van Schewick, B. 2012. Network neutrality and quality of service: What a non-discrimination rule should look like. http://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/downloads/20120611-NetworkNeutrality.pdf.Google Scholar
- Wellman, S. 2007. Comcast is blocking more than BitTorrent, including Lotus Notes. InformationWeek, October 22nd. http://www.informationweek.com/mobile/comcast-is-blocking-more-than-bittorrent- including-lotus-notes/d/d-id/1060589?.Google Scholar
- Wilkin, M. 2011. World of Warcraft issues. http://community.virginmedia.com/t5/Broadband-down-your-phone-line/World-of-Warcraft-Issues-Updated-14-02-11/td-p/161857.Google Scholar
- Wu, T. 2003. Network neutrality, broadband discrimination. J. Telecomm. High Technol. Law 2, 1, 141.Google Scholar
- Wu, T. 2010. Wireless Carterfone. Int. J. Comm. 1, 389--426.Google Scholar
- Wu, T. and Lessig, L. 2003. Ex parte submission in CS Docket no. 02-52. http://www.freepress.net/sites/default/files/fp-legacy/wu_lessig_fcc.pdf.Google Scholar
- Yoo, C. S. 2004. Would mandating broadband network neutrality help or hurt competition? A comment on the end-to-end debate. J. Telecomm. High Tech. Law 3, 1, 23.Google Scholar
Index Terms
Net Neutrality: Discrimination, Competition, and Innovation in the UK and US
Recommendations
Neutral Net Neutrality
SIGCOMM '16: Proceedings of the 2016 ACM SIGCOMM ConferenceShould applications receive special treatment from the network? And if so, who decides which applications are preferred? This discussion, known as net neutrality, goes beyond technology and is a hot political topic. In this paper we approach net ...
QoS-Aware Net Neutrality
INTERNET '09: Proceedings of the 2009 First International Conference on Evolving InternetThis paper proposes a compromise solution to the net neutrality problem, which is one of the key issues in the development process of new Internet applications and services. The solution is to use a QoS architecture, one that would provide service ...






Comments