A Public Option for the Core

ABSTRACT

This paper is focused not on the Internet architecture - as defined by layering, the narrow waist of IP, and other core design principles - but on the Internet infrastructure, as embodied in the technologies and organizations that provide Internet service. In this paper we discuss both the challenges and the opportunities that make this an auspicious time to revisit how we might best structure the Internet's infrastructure. Currently, the tasks of transit-between-domains and last-mile-delivery are jointly handled by a set of ISPs who interconnect through BGP. In this paper we propose cleanly separating these two tasks. For transit, we propose the creation of a "public option" for the Internet's core backbone. This public option core, which complements rather than replaces the backbones used by large-scale ISPs, would (i) run an open market for backbone bandwidth so it could leverage links offered by third-parties, and (ii) structure its terms-of-service to enforce network neutrality so as to encourage competition and reduce the advantage of large incumbents.

References

1. E. Altman, M. K. Hanawal, and R. Sundaresan. Regulation of off-network pricing in a nonneutral network. ACM Trans. Internet Techn., 14(2-3):11:1--11:21, 2014.
2. Aryaka. The Cloud-First WAN. https://www.aryaka.com/.
3. G. S. Becker, D. W. Carlton, and H. S. Sider. Net neutrality and consumer welfare. Journal of Competition Law and Economics, 6(3):497--519, 2010.
4. BEREC. All you need to know about Net Neutrality rules in the EU. https://berec.europa.eu/eng/netneutrality/, 2020.
5. T. Böttger, G. Antichi, E. L. Fernandes, R. di Lallo, M. Bruyere, S. Uhlig, G. Tyson, and I. Castro. Shaping the internet: 10 years of ixp growth. arXiv preprint arXiv:1810.10963, 2018.
6. M. Bourreau, F. Kourandi, and T. Valletti. Net Neutrality with Competing Internet Platforms. CEIS Research Paper 307, Tor Vergata University, CEIS, Feb. 2014.
7. Cato Networks. Global Private Backbone. https://www.catonetworks.com/cato-cloud/global-private-backbone-3/.
8. Y.-C. Chiu, B. Schlinker, A. B. Radhakrishnan, E. Katz-Bassett, and R. Govindan. Are we one hop away from a better internet? In IMC, 2015.
9. Y.-C. Chiu, B. Schlinker, A. B. Radhakrishnan, E. Katz-Bassett, and R. Govindan. Are we one hop away from a better internet? In Internet Measurement Conference, 2015.
10. D. D. Clark, J. Wroclawski, K. R. Sollins, and R. Braden. Tussle in cyberspace: defining tomorrow's internet. In SIGCOMM 2002, 2002.
11. E. H. Clarke. Multipart pricing of public goods. Public choice, pages 17--33, 1971.
12. A. Collard-Wexler, G. Gowrisankaran, and R. Lee. "nash-in-nash" bargaining: A microfoundation for applied work. Journal of Political Economy, 127:163--195, 2019.
13. P. Cramton. Electricity market design. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 33(4):589--612, Nov 2017.
14. G. Crawford, R. Lee, M. Whinston, and A. Yurukoglu. The welfare effects of vertical integration in multichannel television markets. Econometrica, 86:891--954, 2018.
15. J. Dunn. Trump's new FCC boss could make it easier for Internet providers to play favorites. Business Insider, Jan 2017.
16. N. Economides. Economic Features of the Internet and Network Neutrality. In The Oxford Handbook of the Economics of Networks. Oxford University Press, 2016.
17. N. Economides and J. T~g. Network neutrality on the internet: A two-sided market analysis. Information Economics and Policy, 24:91--104, 2012.
18. M. C. Erickson, E. Stallman, D. J. Kalt, A. W. Guhr, C. Libertelli, and C. Wright. Petition to deny of Netflix Inc. Web, Aug 2014. https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7521819696.pdf.
19. P. Faratin, D. D. Clark, S. Bauer, W. Lehr, P. W. Gilmore, and A. Berger. The growing complexity of Internet interconnection. Communications & strategies, page 51, 2008.
20. G. R. Faulhaber. Economics of net neutrality: A review. Communications & Convergence Review, 3(1):53--64, 2011.
21. Federal Communication Commission. Internet Policy Statement. https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-05-150A1.pdf, Sep 2005.
22. J. Feigenbaum, C. H. Papadimitriou, R. Sami, and S. Shenker. A BGP-based mechanism for lowest-cost routing. Distributed Computing, 18(1):61--72, 2005.
23. B. M. Frischmann and B. Van Schewick. Network neutrality and the economics of an information superhighway: A reply to professor yoo. Jurimetrics, pages 383--428, 2007.
24. Google. Google Fiber. https://fiber.google.com/.
25. S. Greenstein, M. Peitz, and T. Valletti. Net neutrality: A fast lane to understanding the trade-offs. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 30:127--150, 2016.
26. T. Groves. Incentives in teams. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, pages 617--631, 1973.
27. GSMA. Comparison of fixed and mobile cost structures. https://www.gsma.com/publicpolicy/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/Tax-Comparison-of-fixed-and-mobile-cost-structures.pdf, 2012.
28. R. W. Hahn and S. J. Wallsten. The economics of net neutrality. The Economist's Voice, June 2006.
29. K. Ho and R. Lee. Insurer competition in health care markets. Econometrica, 85:379--417, 2017.
30. A. Hortaçsu, J. Kastl, and A. Zhang. Bid shading and bidder surplus in the us treasury auction system. American Economic Review, 108(1):147--169, Jan 2018.
31. G. Huston. The death of transit? Web, Oct 2016. https://blog.apnic.net/2016/10/28/the-death-of-transit/.
32. Industry Analysis Division, Federal Communications Comission. Internet Access Services: Status as of December 31, 2017. https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-359342A1.pdf, Dec 2017.
33. S. Knight, H. X. Nguyen, N. J. G. Falkner, R. A. Bowden, and M. Roughan. The internet topology zoo. IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, 29:1765--1775, 2011.
34. J. Krämer, L. Wiewiorra, and C. Weinhardt. Net neutrality: A progress report. Telecommunications Policy, 37(9):794--813, 2013.
35. P. Lambert. Vodafone and Telefonica are overplaying their hand with Google. https://telecoms.com/opinion/Vodafone-and-telefonica-are-overplaying-their-hand-with-google/, Feb 2010.
36. R. S. Lee and T. Wu. Subsidizing creativity through network design: Zero-pricing and net neutrality. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 23(3):61--76, 2009.
37. F. Li, A. A. Niaki, D. R. Choffnes, P. Gill, and A. Mislove. A large-scale analysis of deployed traffic differentiation practices. In SIGCOMM, 2019.
38. N. C. Ltd. About NBN Co. Web, accessed Jun 2020. https://www.nbnco.com.au/corporate-information/about-nbn-co.
39. R. T. B. Ma and V. Misra. The public option: A nonregulatory alternative to network neutrality. IEEE/ACM Trans. Netw., 21(6):1866--1879, Dec 2013.
40. J. Malone, A. Nevo, and J. Williams. The tragedy of the last mile: Economic solutions to congestion in broadband networks. NET Institute Working Paper, 2017.
41. J. Nash. The bargaining problem. Econometrica, 18:155--162, 1950.
42. N. Nisan, T. Roughgarden, E. Tardos, and V. V. Vazirani. Algorithmic Game Theory. Cambridge University Press, USA, 2007.
43. O'Connell, P. Online Extra: At SBC, It's All About "Scale and Scope". Bloomberg Businessweek, 11 2005.
44. Omitted for Double Blind. Personal communication, 2019.
45. A. Parker and R. Waters. Google Accused of YouTube "Free Ride". Financial Times, April 2010.
46. A. Rubinstein. Perfect equilibrium in a bargaining model. Econometrica, 50:97--109, 1982.
47. G. Schneibel and C. Farivar. Deutsche Telekom moves against Apple, Google and net neutrality. DW, https://www.dw.com/en/deutsche-telekom-moves-against-apple-google-and-net-neutrality/a-5439525, Apr 2010.
48. S. Segan. Exclusive: Check Out the Terrible State of US ISP Competition. PCMag UK, Dec 2017.
49. J. J. Spengler. Vertical integration and antitrust policy. Journal of Political Economy, 58(4):347--352, 1950.
50. J. Spolsky. Strategy Letter V. Joel on Software, https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/, June 2002.
51. J. Taylor. NBN amendments clarify cherry-picking. Web, Mar 2011. https://www.zdnet.com/article/nbn-amendments-clarify-cherry-picking/.
52. J. Taylor. Senate passes NBN bills with amendments. Web, Mar 2011. https://www.zdnet.com/article/senate-passes-nbn-bills-with-amendments/.
53. TeleGeography. The state of the network 2020 edition. Web, 2020. https://www2.telegeography.com/hubfs/assets/Ebooks/state-of-the-network-2020.pdf.
54. B. van Schewick. Internet architecture and innovation. MIT Press, 2012.
55. W. Vickrey. Counterspeculation, auctions, and competitive sealed tenders. The Journal of finance, 16(1):8--37, 1961.
56. Wikipedia contributors. Net neutrality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality, 2020.
57. T. Wu. Network neutrality, broadband discrimination. J. on Telecomm. & High Tech. L., 2:141, 2003.
58. C. S. Yoo. Beyond network neutrality. Harvard Journal of Law & Technology, 19:1, 2005.

Index Terms

• Networks

  • Network algorithms

    • Network economics

  • Network types

    • Public Internet